Sunday, December 09, 2007
The Collection, Tithing Controversy, and Christmas Commercialism
The collection is one of Paul's most intriguing projects. Paul walks on eggshells through II Corinthians 8 and 9 as he seeks to inspire the church in Corinth to part with their material goods in order to send them to a group of people in a far off country, who they probably would never meet, and who likely would not have entered their church much less sat down to eat with them. Despite other considerable obstacles including traveling with large sums of money, risking the appearance of mismanaging funds, and the very real possibility that the Christian church in Jerusalem would refuse the tainted though badly needed money, Paul pressed forward with the collection. His reasons for proceeding with this risky and thorny project have implications for our own practice of tithing and our celebration of Christmas
There is an ongoing debate in Christianity over tithe. The Biblical precedent for tithing is circumstantial and nearly exclusively based on the Old Testament. Within Adventism, the debate is not generally over whether or not to tithe, but how and where our tithe money should be used. Those of us who have a more congregational bent would like to see the majority of our tithe kept in our own church for local mission. On the other hand, combining our collective 10 percent with the money from other churches in our area provides financial support for smaller churches, schools, camps, and other ministries, thus effectively expanding our local mission to a larger area. In addition, some of the money then goes up to higher levels of the organization, eventually supporting the international church. Although Paul's collection does not exactly correspond to our practice of tithing, the principle of giving to expand our limited world view and to unite a growing, diverse, global community applies well in both cases.
Always a hot topic around the holidays, Christmas commercialism is gaining in both attention and condemnation this year. Many of the comments in a recent article in the religion section of The Birmingham News suggest the answer is to simply stop giving gifts at Christmas. This may work well for some families. However, there are many who find meaning in the giving of gifts and to deny them this pleasure would only serve to diminish their holiday cheer. For Paul, the collection was never about the money. Instead, it was about the motives inspiring the gift and the relationships revealed and formed in the giving and receiving. If this perspective is carried into our Christmas giving this year, perhaps we can continue our holiday traditions with our humanity intact.
In II Corinthians 10:5, Paul writes that every thought should be taken captive in Christ. Rather than reading this as just another example of Christian elitism, expecting everyone to become like us and accept our point of view, could we live this text out in our experience of the Holiday Season and with intentional thought and Christlike humility seek to bless our family, friends, and the rest of the least of these? The God who became man and moved into the neighborhood has shown us how to be a good giver. This Christmas will you consider with me the way our giving expands our world view, enhances relationships, and helps us become a part of the Kingdom of God?
Here are a few links to websites that may stimulate ideas to enhance our giving this year. If you've got some other ideas, post them below in a comment. Thanks!
Fair trade?
http://tradeasone.com/
Tree hugger?
http://www.treehugger.com/giftguide/
Want a guide for what's good?
http://www.unclemark.org/unclemark2008.pdf
Pass on the gift?
http://www.heifer.org/
Really useful gift?
http://www.adra.org/site/PageServer?pagename=cat07_Ecommerce_home
There is an ongoing debate in Christianity over tithe. The Biblical precedent for tithing is circumstantial and nearly exclusively based on the Old Testament. Within Adventism, the debate is not generally over whether or not to tithe, but how and where our tithe money should be used. Those of us who have a more congregational bent would like to see the majority of our tithe kept in our own church for local mission. On the other hand, combining our collective 10 percent with the money from other churches in our area provides financial support for smaller churches, schools, camps, and other ministries, thus effectively expanding our local mission to a larger area. In addition, some of the money then goes up to higher levels of the organization, eventually supporting the international church. Although Paul's collection does not exactly correspond to our practice of tithing, the principle of giving to expand our limited world view and to unite a growing, diverse, global community applies well in both cases.
Always a hot topic around the holidays, Christmas commercialism is gaining in both attention and condemnation this year. Many of the comments in a recent article in the religion section of The Birmingham News suggest the answer is to simply stop giving gifts at Christmas. This may work well for some families. However, there are many who find meaning in the giving of gifts and to deny them this pleasure would only serve to diminish their holiday cheer. For Paul, the collection was never about the money. Instead, it was about the motives inspiring the gift and the relationships revealed and formed in the giving and receiving. If this perspective is carried into our Christmas giving this year, perhaps we can continue our holiday traditions with our humanity intact.
In II Corinthians 10:5, Paul writes that every thought should be taken captive in Christ. Rather than reading this as just another example of Christian elitism, expecting everyone to become like us and accept our point of view, could we live this text out in our experience of the Holiday Season and with intentional thought and Christlike humility seek to bless our family, friends, and the rest of the least of these? The God who became man and moved into the neighborhood has shown us how to be a good giver. This Christmas will you consider with me the way our giving expands our world view, enhances relationships, and helps us become a part of the Kingdom of God?
Here are a few links to websites that may stimulate ideas to enhance our giving this year. If you've got some other ideas, post them below in a comment. Thanks!
Fair trade?
http://tradeasone.com/
Tree hugger?
http://www.treehugger.com/giftguide/
Want a guide for what's good?
http://www.unclemark.org/unclemark2008.pdf
Pass on the gift?
http://www.heifer.org/
Really useful gift?
http://www.adra.org/site/PageServer?pagename=cat07_Ecommerce_home
Labels: Adventist, Christmas, Corinthians, giving, Jesus, religion, tithe
Comments:
<< Home
Hi, there. Thanks for stopping by Love Notes to Yahweh around the holidays.
I'm obviously late for this discussion, but I deal with the issue of gifts like this... we give one or two things to each other that are really "from the heart". Then we spend most of our focus on ritual. This year, for instance, we did a little ceremony where the children served everyone (including each other) challah dipped in honey. We based it on the O.T. festival of Sukkot and considered how God is our sukkah (tent) now. It is these kinds of rituals that my children look forward to more than anything. (And me too!)
Post a Comment
I'm obviously late for this discussion, but I deal with the issue of gifts like this... we give one or two things to each other that are really "from the heart". Then we spend most of our focus on ritual. This year, for instance, we did a little ceremony where the children served everyone (including each other) challah dipped in honey. We based it on the O.T. festival of Sukkot and considered how God is our sukkah (tent) now. It is these kinds of rituals that my children look forward to more than anything. (And me too!)
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]